Shared briefing · Australia

Curious what would happen if you tried something different? Run your own simulation →

Confidential · Briefing No. 102

Impact Assessment for the Government of Australia

Policy Impact Simulation for Australia

Motion under review

"Impose a major tax on Australia's gas giants and use the revenue for households, public services, and the energy transition."

Net Outcome

Favourable

Confidence

73%

73%

Risk Level

moderate

Executive summary

A stronger tax on Australia's gas giants would likely raise significant public revenue and prove popular if framed around resource ownership and cost-of-living relief. The upside is highest if the tax targets economic rents and windfall profits rather than normal investment returns. The main risks are investment disputes, lower future exploration, legal complexity, and an intense campaign from the gas industry.

Reading the report

Every % shown is a probability estimate, not a magnitude. It represents the model's estimated likelihood that the adjacent claim materialises — that an effect occurs, an event unfolds in its time horizon, a stakeholder group supports the policy, or a tail risk is realised. The Confidence figure above reflects how certain the model is in its overall assessment. Hover any bar for context.

Impact by Domain

Economic

3 effects

A rent-style tax can capture public value from finite resources while preserving viable investment if designed carefully.

  • Large revenue upliftmajor

    A tougher resource rent or windfall profits regime could raise billions over time, especially during high LNG price periods.

    75%
  • Investment deterrence riskmoderate

    Poorly designed retrospective taxation could reduce future gas investment or increase required returns.

    52%
  • Budget flexibilitymajor

    Revenue could fund bill relief, public services, or clean-energy infrastructure without broad tax hikes.

    68%

Environmental

3 effects

The tax can support the transition if revenue is directed away from fossil-fuel dependence.

  • Clean-energy fundingmajor

    Earmarking revenue for transmission, storage, electrification, and industrial decarbonisation would accelerate transition capacity.

    64%
  • Gas expansion slowsmoderate

    Higher effective tax rates may make marginal gas projects less attractive.

    55%
  • Export emissions remainmoderate

    Taxing profits does not directly reduce the emissions from exported gas combustion overseas.

    80%

Political

3 effects

The measure has strong populist appeal but faces a sophisticated industry campaign.

  • Public fairness messagemoderate

    Australians are likely to support the idea that multinational gas producers should pay more for public resources.

    78%
  • Industry advertising blitzmoderate

    Gas firms would warn of job losses, sovereign risk, and higher energy prices.

    86%
  • State-federal bargainingmoderate

    Resource states would demand guarantees on jobs, royalties, and regional investment.

    65%

Social

3 effects

The policy is strongest when people can see a direct household dividend or bill relief.

  • Cost-of-living reliefmoderate

    Using some revenue for targeted household support would strengthen legitimacy.

    66%
  • Regional anxietymoderate

    Gas-producing communities may fear job losses and reduced investment.

    57%
  • Trust in resource ownershipmoderate

    A successful tax could restore confidence that public resources deliver public benefits.

    60%

International

3 effects

The policy would be watched by investors and LNG buyers, but Australia has room to tax rents without becoming an outlier.

  • Investor scrutinymoderate

    International investors would examine whether changes are prospective, rules-based, and stable.

    72%
  • Limited buyer disruptionminor

    Existing LNG contracts and Australia's supply reliability would likely remain intact.

    69%
  • Global precedentmoderate

    The measure would align with broader efforts to tax resource windfalls during price spikes.

    58%

Projected Timeline

Immediate · 0–3 months

A fairness fight begins

  • Government announces a rent or windfall tax aimed at gas super-profits.

    86%
  • Gas companies launch a campaign warning about sovereign risk and jobs.

    88%

Short term · 3–12 months

Design details determine credibility

  • Treasury designs deductions, thresholds, and anti-avoidance rules.

    76%
  • Resource states negotiate regional investment guarantees.

    64%

Medium term · 1–3 years

Revenue and litigation arrive together

  • Early revenue supports household relief or energy-transition programs.

    63%
  • Companies challenge aspects of implementation or restructure finances to minimise liabilities.

    57%

Long term · 3–10 years

Stability decides investment impact

  • If rules are stable, the tax becomes a normal part of Australia's resource regime.

    58%
  • If repeatedly changed, it increases perceived sovereign risk for resource projects.

    43%

Stakeholder Reception

Australian households

Benefits

They benefit if revenue funds bill relief, services, or public investment.

Likely to support
72%

Gas producers

Harmed

Their after-tax profits fall and planning uncertainty rises.

Likely to support
5%

Resource-state workers

Neutral

They may gain from regional funds but fear lower future investment.

Likely to support
42%

Clean-energy sector

Benefits

Dedicated transition spending expands markets for transmission, storage, and electrification.

Likely to support
82%

Federal budget

Benefits

Additional resource revenue improves fiscal options without broad-based tax rises.

Likely to support
75%

Tail Risks & Unintended Consequences

Poor tax design reduces investment more than intended

high
45%

MitigationTax economic rents prospectively with clear thresholds and stable rules.

Industry avoidance reduces collections

moderate
56%

MitigationStrengthen transfer-pricing, debt-loading, and deduction rules.

Regional backlash

moderate
52%

MitigationDedicate a visible share of revenue to affected regions and worker transition.

Revenue volatility

moderate
62%

MitigationUse windfall receipts for one-off investments or stabilisation funds, not only permanent spending.

Historical Precedents

Australia's Petroleum Resource Rent Tax debates

Repeated disputes over deductions and LNG revenue showed the complexity of taxing gas rents.

Relevance: Directly relevant to designing a stronger but administrable gas tax.

UK and EU windfall taxes on energy companies

Governments captured some excess profits during price spikes while firms warned about investment effects.

Relevance: Shows both political appeal and design trade-offs.

Norway's petroleum taxation model

High public capture of resource rents coexisted with a stable investment environment.

Relevance: Demonstrates that high resource taxation can work when predictable and institutionally strong.

Circulate the Briefing

If this simulation gave you pause — or fresh conviction — share it with a friend, a colleague, or a citizen who ought to think this through. Every shared briefing widens the chamber.

https://ideavsreality.com/s/N4IgbiBcCMA0ICcCmAHA9ggLlUCCWAzgNYFQDauhRUIACmhgASYCGAHowCZIF4DmAO0bJOAVwDGPRngFgemALZIBmRgoxJmACxZCZmZd04h4BJHPyYAnjS38tJkAryZ+LV2gE0AKu0ZJxTzRncWFlTAJGFAQ0AhQA1zkAGytGAHcXLUZxJKQWBG1kAi00JM5I3U5GAlYAI1zhUVyCADpHaLRallq8JJcbSAAWAFYAX1hKYhoASQExGoRUljA0PE5dSTCxSUjApNzxDwFSU3MkSwGnNG4EdyRHZ1c+dzxPGgBlTGQBPkwtZWYt2OADNzgBaaJ4cQyPiwLhIWqYMFJNAsTgwuGVeHbI6NZpteAdLo9PrWKDDABs40m1EgIAASkg+K8BCwkowuuIiEkWMVHGYLP0aOobncHi43EcaAARJDo8R3RgsRhgQh4eqaYr5TRoYFhOQCUSaTBoJXA0GHOVhZmeCpzdIYIjnQG6XhHAkgIndXpCyDDABM1MQVBojINRpVpRepJsp0FZLpIvOYvgj0lLJoAFUzOkZJxgWz2chJHgUBFGMCmJ4kGDdXqZHIakoVJEmDVvX0CC9PBXRHMCHCBGhVJ4UlFzgpdOFqvE5jCPV6Sb6KYGALrwTjBFgyUiQCggVlKGgAUUCQ5CjiQ5oSu-3rkwuRoABl8nxNMhw5pRCg+sDsKmWEEFxRG4YUWAAKwwflwjwZtsDpdA3TwORHG4AhxHwMsMzpABBZg0FEPh-gKIoCIQTZvhHAoMjmAt9iiGJgRcSJkGZJRsgIsphG3HMST6W1GDQCxmFgpA4R4eJoULVIxHwH5GDsIjGCfAA5ABxBioU0eJ8GuVp2hiYkfQTAB2MYJhAe9HzpWZG0UaduAMBBvgokMAKAzAQPuRNrmTAxoJUUSVBoAQmReFCNx4DDSylOl6AwMc0P4UKqmQL5YkkxJjXYbshECJpUrlCRNGBURPOQRhnkiBt5DgwSChkDC8hzZAAEdRDwEQwnK44F0MjtfQDIMrO8kAACEQLfVRgVyNh1WM2MnEAgRgNAxMIKg05ArgmhEIlCKQDQ6KsLeOkw2UCN8q40r7T4sI+ivOEUFEeooWqc5VR2OEmByPIBDBZRzj4VIZGBW4FgkcrNAyP4CNUWoYjRZg-DsJ19MJfqlwTCkAA5RnXEACFEBRJ0WGg8MosEaisBpWA4BU8pYMtRAq57XtCMA2QjMHggrGQXHfHgyJ2dI7AaaIeA+mEVTwboGhqptpzwPUksEK0FWQUr9isNog0PUbj1kTrPDgtlL2vQ5b1AEaaAAYVyXQAdChBgd7OcfgeZbVtGydIIQALXB2hDYn2+5IvQzDYpAY98lJohpY-C6SqYL5XWcAheE8OEagwQCxP8A4vmVqFcsxe081EBZZfZbgNdqTxCFyh0CqVcRJFyW4DBdY4JR7BUUBYaFrD6zoBuxwZhpcayQDU3l-DYAee57AgUTSE4lo8rzhV8zuw8JmCg89EOstQqLI+wkAAAl7GdK8LSy5GOF3yJJ1SScnTUV8ZDZSq546cCbyMGaBUTAqdDjISQCPIyMZyTmWtlPA2C8MCqCQOnTOxwwiThkJ7Tea0riin8ltQO4QQpIDKrcJIp8I4xQvr4Oa8kOhMXLJuKQQ5VDomLA+VIIhiraE0Kgwg6DIg8wUPPdAWArRVQ4goWoldcRCXOGYXkUCx4DBxgABnxqYYmpNLjeH+I-bIuhqjfnEaoP4xogRIR7MrfUSdpCRA4QkK0LA0gsFSCIissReBJDBKVJANdUCGGUJIXWFl9Y0HoKSEulD4B3xvOQeBD5Rq0Ben0UIBZOqhQzmoHgXY3w4JWp5PBSZd4ByCvBI+SEDpHXPqdEAOE5EUNlhg7UQC8BOjHCaExKAzF8OkNwZUfx3BqCaK4VkRwf5SI6NsRR1QSgtwHm-DQXiChs3SWEAgwseAqKxgMEyeMLI2xsnMJpSxOAWFcLweSr1MAAC9Cne23gQveZhtokLpKFZ4J9w7HSjrPYRnUFCRDSJxKobiEBCF1IwSCtQgHeJ4NnBRyBkrCCoGXKoiliL+Gdq7SEOxdkLSgDjKkRyEEfFYAYPxcpkzsi6C7bcK0PbuSKVvHyLzymH1CuQs2vy6leDOkLFmmx2wGBBWC+Ek57R8FEPkXQBgpA9lhQOYQaArBslcIipU9pWIsh-greyKhCUwMgBSMYBMiYk3yHogxSheQs00DoSICxPB8CiGgZ6nZVBM3iD-WR01B5SGVFslAdgaglwMFUCuCxUgKgUAPZKYTQARLpO8NAUlYkgHiZbRJllyV0ltrEJEupkTIQTgEvAV5HnFJ9jvFM+93nBWDtUvetSaH1OzNLLZ7FE6GmTgUVgLskCRoUgRMwJQuJE16cg5uk6vjKF+P8IQuRmSB0HjrAyo89lQApKSpJ09GQ2lZOyXQc1h2LUnLg2tHKiEVNId8iBVC-kXwBRCGI2xpaBBJn2CUUhX4VjyAUWF8KM5Bp1UVSQUbZC1XCMawaJlJ7JJ8AgOR0ghCkWFTqNIztiilmrWy-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-WMBO2t2WCk54xF5mTvwlEQWZDhhyAIwRpbGLhg9BAusCbEL6KFXNZwWyO4NJUtSyKBB1V0EOPsItlSUXqlT-MhZDHbiUFUEZUip3gkYcxD0byluVLh4+jGW7pMkqDE7t3c8v2L0rZEHkvusjKjjQmnHEKmVuu6MbrZFgkCovwMQbVVRlXx5I8tuL8PFzp45-AEo+A7n1NguH2WhCQD-DRPb0aeFMmQryXzIi8MmQ7hAJn13Vss2u+Q81FmMkeDJUcRBo4Kq-hFAsyqrE8q8BgmWKsdY7H3xNBZzD2Lq2KGs9UVAEye7N+kcZFszDdrO4SIL5YcUfQWI9TLOyOqGVOVVLZ-RbO9T5N-XlSTNPE1CkCeAmfvPAQfZLYoZBAAfScgUEcAn04CnxlH3xx0cm3CSEPxIMK2yBEHmhgTX3CA3yzxPHyBuydwjCnTMUiAWXHVKEKkc0D0BhdisDBFTh7lxA6D4FuGBTb0bST2PhTzQLZ2xgAGZ2DltC141dB89sgdB9gF1DMatLZBJ6x41chTZ5ESJ5AUNDgHU+ZWQH9SdTRnAVp05NA+gx588VDE9714sP9t0-QENsCMBcD6kR9iZiCJwyC8gKDCtQw+DDN7RokH0ex8h8A5B8IppiJV8LIs9OCt8bI9QGsg0Kp2wNQ4QLFDFRMv0g1GAhwEBJwQd8gRw9R1dmkWBLsKdADdUlAgikCyMu8pMTVhhDlQAuCKiwhfVI0xwytdA3xWtpBVBGpkBeQpAdISw5Aqha9zh68cdG8iBVlBi+MGI0AAFLZRiuUwoJj0DfRBhdCoiB96kUQfgEj2ikjJ9UjU06gFp4RoQ0I0NoClZDDDhV8LVWAnQLNFFc1FCCIUByYmkztjFhDzNRD15YIB5oS6RRNQpxNLwF4eR0tksUdUgiSrwXBpBKj0i3ZygORegiwK1Hp3oEBPotUmBhNwSYMjV+RTEiCnsK0Shrgv8etQBkTvwaAAVrjZkZdHA8TB5KkdB2i5RSSfxdBcpFN68CgWA-xwRydY9yw6IT17RtSBBK9GBfdzhWB9BuFCAECBCRTmc+hxTjA-QgwZTUTBUAC+MqZKVoZHRET4AVSCSVseVvMySdSo4qTP5UhngZAKwYhRFdUMt2QbpmTVdQR8h4U0hnRSooZ+TFZBTtFp0sBCDRSPSGAvTBgpSQBfS7YHZ-pJDXYzBDgFsIzKkaSSS4lYyKSqD5Q7gqhZDrEhAat3Y3U8tF5mS45h1hEU4rE0EWRs5pc842sAkEh8AmIFR3QhTKzMBqz3S8BPTiVGzmy6QAAxGlChBXTgKaZUqE3ssTZiLU8k3U3CTgdESZNkgMiiRkvEmIRsPmdCH+D1Y-XHBZeGAnJrHYsc-XZ0iTV0qsmss8usr-c1eAYsYIZsdYKOWgGISQK0GGYvIxTWJoRKaglKS4yQMEAPJgGiYPfYN9XUZiR+QcYcbVJUTFdNKIH9B+XIMAHWRgAAWRYA-gaKqMiA6EsKynqKsQHkojayKEIFYBUHwiVBWDWA2CQAAG5sQI1BZPwtLVReANRTMRCuJbsOSMzj1u4Jy2tfpHZ2zJcwZeQvhIYHUWhGAUd3UVMHF2lnsTdiSoRq56SNijFmYih-AzwzdQgDdoLjcmoXh5IS8dAwDQgDU6phjIFSSAhQs5BCDLVdEqMXUNMB0-AexeiMSBipFmR5UcsuIazuEeJNRkpi4GYuM0keNGSsQOh8j0BPV8zbEPLw8lQYg+xGNKc0BsNFE7AUBm8OIahaxgRS1VR5JbKnM-KDFvxeBuAgqsVNNbEGjydB0ppIhTdzw+qWxlrmLzTrjxNuISttBjE2iOjSzDVVA0oWZepdrUc3szjKtNAcqHJCBnoxU4RV4iyypXDZyURO41ygEwp2Rc9Zp+g2tjF9BlAcxS9twcdPEGipFo0vgN14BkVCxCDeQzAM4g5QAWM1gQlvITJtCcKqBqyzhKEocyl4BQpjy4Zmjdp1CUJxhx91LoiFQkhCDQcaVnc9wGadi0TTt-CBjaBh0YhchiZGB-9KdGRNK6F4QugxVHBBbghRpGRFirRxtIbFVhIjBIYWRZdlJ1I7E+15k5qrQGj0a8t+hrDH5pYpEDcPQHNzA9KZROoEheDhL5UtLVYbTg11M3wChVc0RvD1LbhLKpE6ZnMFQzAswABpZa48TMIPR6umRVIQNy6RPPHgU2sqIWukd3CwT3Dg6KqGQ482+eHYWSxiDi2SenfAEVJnNGUWXoEqIFEFfIWi6vMqL6uqHzCTUOzmB-D4EoNeDkYcLIZTCUKWpUXpPIC0yzGil0bgNa4EfSIMPO0aFSDANxKwAY+IdKLW0ROmJuJMTNM2tzK+ewAS9mdu1w6FXjQCu6wIX2moUizIJUIAyysGzS5QVUGIVu8sxAbcleyQKg9QY4VOMVN61QLFOi7KfLXEfTUFBAc4tIJdBiOUKEDrDIqDcNTyP8scCqvgG3MWpQVgHAEAfKFQbnBpdE-w9oPnaEOumyeNWIQzT+P2QxGqwRi7SIBqlpI7e0MzfpXtbmJgLE8-J6Xq0IMwLkrSC-e0Bo6u8c3uAQXWUYIAA

Concluding Counsel · Sealed

The AI's recommendation awaits

Form your own judgment from the briefing above before consulting the model's verdict.

Discussion

0 comments

Join the discussion — sign in to comment.

Sign in to comment →

Loading comments…